Refinery29 editor Christene Barberich on building audience of millions

Christene Barberich is the cofounder and editor in
chief of Refinery29.
Refinery29

• Christene Barberich is the cofounder and editor in
  chief of Refinery29.
• Refinery29 is a lifestyle and news media company
  primarily for young women.
• Across all of its global sites, social media accounts,
  and events, Refinery said it will reach 425 million people this
  year.
• Barberich said her greatest lessons as a leader have
  been around learning when to pass on responsibilities and
  finding what keeps her the most engaged.

Christene Barberich is the cofounder and CEO of Refinery29, a
media company focused on empowering women by starting
conversations about body image, politics, and careers. Refinery29
said it would connect with 425 million people this year across
its site, social media, videos, and live events.

Before founding Refinery in 2005 — with Philippe von Borries,
Justin Stefano, and Piera Gelardi — Barberich spent her career in
media and helped build the scrappy City magazine. The lessons she
learned there gave her the confidence she needed to take on
Refinery 29, which would turn out to be a more ambitious project
than anyone expected.

Listen to the full episode here:

Subscribe to “This Is Success” on Apple Podcasts, Google Play, or
your favorite podcast app. Check out previous episodes with:

Transcript edited for clarity.

Christene Barberich: I always knew I wanted to
be involved in storytelling, whether that was going to be in
magazines, books, film. It was important to me. I feel deeply
passionate about helping people, today even, to craft a narrative
around something that was really important to them, they feel
will really be useful and resonate with other people. Nothing
beats true stories. When the opportunity came up to possibly take
the lead-editor role at City, I just felt it was exactly the
right opportunity where I could figure this out and see if I
could do it under the radar without completely humiliating myself
and prove to myself that I could run a magazine. I could craft a
point of view. I helped hire a creative director. We staffed the
whole team, we won an ASME [American Society of Magazine Editors] award, we got nominated for general excellence. It was really
life-affirming in a lot of ways.

Richard Feloni: What did you learn from that
experience that you brought to Refinery?

Barberich: Honestly, if I had to distill it, it
would be confidence, because I had worked at Condé Nast for
nearly a decade before that, and I got incredible experience
there being an editor, working with incredibly talented writers,
collaborating with different teams, and crafting great stories.
But I really always knew that I wanted to run something. I was in
my early 30s. It was really about proving to myself that I had
the instincts and I had what it took to run something and make it
successful and create a brand that was valuable to people. I miss
that magazine.

Creating a new way of looking at things

Cofounders Justin Stefano,
Barberich, Philippe von Borries, and Piera Gelardi at the book
launch party for Barberich’s and Gelardi’s book “Style
Stalking.”
Theo Wargo/Getty
Images

Feloni: And if you enjoyed this experience of
creating something so much, why was there initially some
reluctance to help build Refinery?

Barberich: Because I knew how hard it was. And
also there was a lot of fear on my part because we didn’t know
what was happening in digital media at that point. There wasn’t a
lot of evidence at that point that this sort of medium was going
to literally become the backbone of everything that every
business is. I think we had a feeling that there was that
potential, but at that point I was in my mid-30s and a lot of my
friends were getting married at that point, having children. And
here I’m basically forgoing a salary, moving in with my boyfriend
to save money, and figuring out how to make this work so we can
actually get this up and running. I think that it’s hard because
at a certain point in your life you do crave security, you do
crave a little bit more permanence, and even though I did crave
those things, what I’ve always craved more is opportunity. I
think that I cannot say no to an exciting invitation to do
something I feel needs to be done. I cannot say no to it … I
was, like, “Oh my God, I have to do this!” This is in 2004 when
we all started talking and starting to hatch a plan for
Refinery29. There was a lot of interest and discussion about
whether or not people would buy things online if e-commerce was
going to be a viable means of retail.

Feloni: It’s funny how that was still a question
back then.

Barberich: Oh — it was such a question.
I do remember having a lot of meetings with very big established
national department stores. And they were, like, “Yeah, well, we
don’t really think we’re going to do this e-commerce thing. We
don’t really think that’s the way people want to shop.” Everyone
had mobile phones at that point, but people weren’t really using
them in a way that was facilitating their everyday life in the
way that it is now. So they were really interested in doing
something I think was really revolutionary at the time, which was
so exciting to me. They were thinking at that point they wanted
it to be almost a search engine for independent boutiques in big
cities because these were really businesses that didn’t have the
resources to be able to reach a bigger audience.

But when we launched, in 2005 — just give you a sense of the
landscape at that point and digital — Twitter wasn’t around. I
feel like it was Facebook and Net-a-Porter, and I can’t really
think of anybody else at that point, at least in our space, that
had this really massive presence that were succeeding and that
really gave us encourage about what it was we wanted to
accomplish.

So after we launched in 2005 in June, it took us about six months
to get everything up and running and to build the site and to
design the initial execution. It was very clear to us very early
on that it was the storytelling that people were responding to.
And they were buying things. But I think what we were seeing was
really exciting and really rewarding, was the storytelling that
we were attaching to the people, the trends, the products, and
street style was a really interesting phenomenon at that point.

There was just a really deep and passionate interest in real
people, not just models, not about this beauty ideal that we have
seen for decades in traditional magazines. And that was something
Piera and I really loved and identified with.

We didn’t really feel like we identified with traditional women’s
media, didn’t really speak our language. Both of us read music
magazines and men’s magazines and different kinds like The New
Yorker and stuff like that, because women’s magazines … the
sense of instilling these rules in people, things you can do and
you can’t do, wasn’t really our perspective. And it still isn’t
and those initial principles really have driven Refinery29
forward and informed so many of the choices that we’ve made and
it’s really at the seat of our foundation and I think has been an
enormous part of our success. I think that having a really
strong, honest and active mission that you can not just talk
about but you can actually live and practice in your work and in
your everyday life has been the game-changer for us in a lot of
ways.

Feloni: It was a way of connecting with an
audience in a way that previous magazines hadn’t.

Barberich: Yeah.

Feloni: More personal.

Barberich: I think that a lot of those magazines
have something special to offer, for sure. But I think it was
more that Piera and I were really interested in the chance to
communicate with people online. At that point, a lot of content
makers on digital weren’t turning on their comments. I don’t know
if you remember that, when The New York Times didn’t have
comments and there was … This was a long time ago. But I think
in the beginning, it was helpful for us because we got to mine
all this incredible information and help really steer us to a lot
of the content and the stories that we pursued in the years to
go. So it really was an important facet of how we actually
developed our content strategy and building that connection to
our audience and our community is still such an important part of
our success and our longevity, and I think for anybody it is.

Feloni: And in setting the foundation at the
very beginning, was there any difference to having two male
cofounders for a woman’s brand?

Barberich: Well, I think in the beginning we
weren’t even sure it was going to be a women’s-media company.

Feloni: So it evolved.

Barberich: I think what was happening, and we
were all paying attention to this, we really wanted to be of use
to people. We still have a small male audience. They’re there.
Certainly not as sizable as our audience of women, but it was the
women that were really responding. They were the ones that felt
we’re filling a void, and that was really satisfying. Philippe
and Justin has always been incredibly receptive to my and Piera’s
opinions, and we don’t always agree. It’s hard to have four
founders, especially after 14 years, next year. To be still
together at this point is a testament to our commitment to our
audience and our customers and certainly our team, but it’s
difficult. It’s really difficult to compromise, especially for
someone like me who has very strong opinions about things. I
think when you’re an editor, you see things. You see them in your
head in a different kind of way and that’s the way you want to
apply them. It’s been a tremendous life lesson over the last
decade really learning how to compromise creatively and also
compassionately, because I think that your success depends on it.

Feloni: Can you give an example of maybe a
conversation that was a significant decision for the company,
where you had to learn to do that compromise you’re talking
about?

Barberich: Well, I think a big one is when we
hired our chief content officer. I was always the lead content
person in the operation, and when video really began to be an
important facet of any robust international media company’s
vision, and at the time, I didn’t have experience in video and
originals.

Amy Emmerich, she was our head of video, and we were meeting with
people who could be our chief content officer. At that point, you
really have to set your ego aside and really think about what is
going to be best for the company. I’m very secure in my talent
and my experience and in my ability to make great work, but I was
also really excited about the opportunity to learn from somebody
and to really develop my own toolbox. And Amy was somebody that
had a completely different background than me. She worked at
Vice; she’d done documentary films. She was really just an
interesting maker. It was hard to find somebody who didn’t just
have the potential to drive content across all these different
mediums, but who was really awesome, who really loved what
Refinery29 stood for.

I recommended her for the chief content officer role. And I was
super excited about it. But when she was moving into this role —
I still say this to her sometimes — I was reassured by the fact
that if she was in a room making big decisions about the
direction of our content and I wasn’t there, I knew that she was
speaking on my behalf. I knew that she had the best of intentions
when it came to protecting and preserving and nourishing our
brand and making sure that we did not lose sight of the mission
that we all felt so committed to.

Feloni: So as core to this idea of compromise,
was it learning how to set aside ego and how to trust more?

Barberich: Yeah. It’s absolutely that. I think
that when you’re building a company, for better or for worse, you
have blinders on in some ways. People have blind spots, and I
think that because you’ve done something a certain way and it’s
worked. But I think that, especially in the climate that we’re in
right now, it’s like the industry is changing so rapidly. How
things are monetized, how things are distributed, how things are
packaged and you have to be able to adapt really quickly. You
can’t really let your ego get in the way of that. Otherwise you
lose. And I knew that not only had I fought for that title at the
time, it wouldn’t have been right, I wasn’t prepared for it, I
would have had to learn on the job which would have been very
disruptive and I also wouldn’t have had a mentor. Somebody who
could really teach me about how to integrate these new methods
into our infrastructure, and Amy really did that.

Going global

Barberich, her cofounders,
and their executive team at a corporate event in
May.
Jamie McCarthy/Getty
Images

Feloni: At what point in the very early days did
it go from taking a look to fashion scenes into becoming more of,
as say, this lifestyle brand, where it was much more broader in
scope? When did that shift happen?

Barberich: It all happened in the first five
years. And as I said earlier, it was really about looking at the
performance of what stories were doing well and what people were
sharing, what they were commenting on.

We did this piece that we ended up getting sponsored. It was one
of our earliest sponsored programs, and it was the month of hair.
We cast it ourselves with people that we knew, and we let these
women do their own hair. So, every day we just featured a new
woman with a different kind of hair, frizzy hair, curly hair,
straight hair, shaved hair. It was every kind of hair, natural
hair. It’s such a simple idea, but it was so revolutionary and
people loved it. I think that was really one of the keys to us
understanding where content, storytelling, and resources were
really heading.

We knew that we wanted to be problem solving for people. We
wanted our content to be of use, not just inspirational, but also
essential to their everyday lives. So when we started to
experiment across food, across beauty. That was a big moment for
us because, again, it was moving away from this traditional
beauty ideal and beauty standards that we felt as though women
had really outgrown, and really speaking to a new generation of
women that really wanted to see themselves reflected back. And
that’s how we got into body positivity in diversity, and just
really making sure that the face of our brand and the content and
the headlines in every way where we were present in our
audience’s lives, that it reflected what really put us on the map
in the first place.

And now, with everything that’s happening with our current
administration, politically and culturally, it’s become such an
important moment for us to have a really big impact in news and
breaking news. I think that we have an incredible team that’s led
by our executive editor, Anne Cohen, and the kind of opportunity
we have to even just to get women out to vote in the midterm
elections is just enormously important. And just providing,
again, resources, information that’s useful to them that we
really feel enhances their lives.

And a lot of times, what we’ll talk about on the site is really
controversial, and sometimes not everybody loves it and that’s
OK. But I think it’s important to start to broach these sensitive
topics and really opened up a dialogue about them, because I
think it is the things that people don’t know about that they
fear the most. We really see that as a big responsibility and
opportunity to be able to responsibly report out some of those
topics.

And I’m sure you and your team know this. You hope that you
mostly get it right. I love the idea of getting it right all the
time. I think that when you’re publishing this much content this
fast, it’s hard to get it all right, but I think that you have to
be able to learn from the mistakes and the times when your tone
is off, or, you know, the headline is a little insensitive.

Feloni: Or it doesn’t register with the
audience.

Barberich: Yeah. And I think sometimes you can’t
see those things until after it’s out there in the world, like
living a life and people are reacting to it, and you’re, like,
“Oh, I didn’t really see that.” And again, you can be in your own
bubble in a way. That’s why it’s so important to have these open
conversations with your colleagues, and certainly an ongoing
dialogue with the audience.

When I was first interviewing editors for our UK office, I was
hearing about how much Refinery29 meant to women in the UK
because they felt like a lot of the women’s media outlets were so
conservative there. The same with Germany. Realizing, when you
get out of your usual, everyday world and you realize, “Wow, this
site has really meant something to people.” And honestly that’s
what matters to me. I hate disappointing people. When I feel like
I’ve disappointed an employee, when I feel like I’ve disappointed
a segment of our audience, when they have felt ignored or
overlooked or misunderstood, I take that personally. I probably
shouldn’t, but I do, because I really, really care. And there are
a lot of people like me in our company that care and really take
the job home with them because of that mission.

Feloni: And what is your ultimate vision for
Refinery? Is it keep getting bigger and bigger, as big as it can
get, or is there a point where you want to keep it within like a
certain sphere?

Barberich: Well, I think that the vision is
always to really spread the gospel everywhere we can, where we
really feel like our audience needs us. It’s just having a chance
to merge our audience with other people’s audiences, and reach
even more people with important forms of storytelling that we
really feel don’t just change our industry but change other
industries, and really help to move society and culture forward.

Lessons in confidence

“I think that’s a huge
responsibility as an executive in a company, certainly as a
founder, is to really be conscious of the contribution that
you’re making.”
Craig Barritt/Getty
Images

Feloni: Looking at the entirety of your career,
what would you say was the biggest challenge that you’ve had to
overcome?

Barberich: In this situation, at this scale,
it’s confidence. It’s having the confidence in myself that I am
an important piece of this operation, and that the people that I
choose to join us in that mission are also the right people to be
doing those jobs. I think that, when things get to be at this
scale, it’s like being on the roof or the top floor of the Empire
State building. It’s like, “Whoa, what’s going on here?” You
start to really feel the gravity of success and failure. When
you’re making a magazine that’s circulated to 35,000 people, you
feel like you have your arms around all the consequences that
could possibly like blow up in your face.

Feloni: And if you’re in a moment where you’re
dealing with that anxiety or the gravity of some decisions you’re
making, how would you deal with that as a leader? Does that
become a danger at some point, if you’re feeling anxiety when you
need to be reassuring to everyone on your team?

Barberich: Sure. I would love to think that I am
the most composed person all the time, even in the most stressful
moments, but I’m not. I’m sure that I have reacted in meetings or
lead a meeting or had a conversation even, and people were, like,
“What is up with her?” Or maybe even said worse things. Who
knows? What is the gift is that I’m aware of it. I’m very
self-aware. I think I’m really open to feedback. I don’t have an
office. We’re moving to a new floor in our building, and it’ll be
the first time in all this time that I will have an office and
I’m really tense about it because I really like being in contact
with everybody on my team. So I actually had them create this
sort of sliding door so I can open it up, so I can still kind of
feel connected to what’s happening.

But I think that I really pay attention to how people react to
the kind of feedback that I give, to the kind of direction that I
give, to the kind of criticism that I give, because I know how I
feel when it’s given to me. That’s the thing that makes me feel
good when I go home at night, is feeling like I wasn’t an a–hole
and I wasn’t being indignant about trying to get my way, and I
used to be that way.

Feloni: How did you learn that?

Barberich: I think you just listen to yourself.
You have to sort of be outside yourself, not just inside
yourself, and whether it’s a one-on-one or you’re in a huge
executive meeting with 25 people. There have been meetings where
I’ve said something and it’s literally like lifted everybody up,
and I’ve seen moments where I’ve said something and it’s really
brought the meeting down. I think that you always want to do the
former. You always want to be enhancing, additive, to what’s
happening. I think that’s a huge responsibility as an executive
in a company, certainly as a founder, is to really be conscious
of the contribution that you’re making. Am I moving things
forward? Or am I becoming a roadblock? You have to be able to ask
yourself those questions.

Feloni: How do you define success?

Barberich: I think that, to me, I’m the happiest
and feel the most in balance and successful when I feel like I’m
listening to my inner voice and that I am actually present in my
life, I’m not just on this treadmill churning stuff like and not
feeling any personal connection to it. I think the reality is, in
many businesses, is that there’s a lot of times that you’re on
that treadmill and you’re just getting out the door, and you’re
just moving sh– off your desk, and answering emails, and taking
care of a lot of the housekeeping. But success to me is feeling
like I am not playing small and that I am really fully present in
my work and in my life. Making sure that I am constantly
accounting for those decisions that I have to make.

I think it was the late [self-help author] Wayne Dyer that said
it, but it was all about the surge of energy that you get when
you make a decision. It’s dwelling too long in the place of
indecision that really brings you down. It’s like when people
can’t move forward, when they can’t just like make a decision and
move on, whether or not that decision is the right decision, but
it allows them to just forge ahead into the future and to start
doing new things. That is where the energy comes from.

I think that, to me, is success, is feeling that you have
momentum in your life and that you’re not stuck. And that if you
are stuck, that you have the courage and you’re able to sort of
access the good counsel that you need in order to get unstuck
because I think that that’s also a reality of running a business,
is that there are places when you’re stuck. It’s like a
department that’s stuck, it’s a leader who’s stuck, or it’s a
team that’s stuck. I think that it’s our jobs to really help
people get unstuck.

Ideally, we want to make all the right decisions, so we don’t
have to encounter those difficult conversations and moments, or
have to take difficult measures to do something to make a change.
But inevitably, you’re not doing a good job unless you’re f—ing
up a little bit. It’s like you kind of need to be out there.
You’ve got to get your hands dirty a little bit. You have to just
see what you’re made of and what the team is made of and what is
possible, because otherwise it just becomes this very generic,
very safe, very predictable kind of timeline, and that doesn’t
interest me at all, and I don’t think it interests a lot of
people who are drawn to startups and drawn to building things.

Feloni: And what advice would give to someone
just starting out who would want to have a career like yours?

Barberich: Well, I mean, I think that it really
starts with putting your ego aside. I think that I had very, very
big ambitions that I was going to be an editor right out of
college. I had to be an assistant for a very long time. I didn’t
get my official editor job until I was 26. That felt late to me.
I was really scared that I was falling behind, but the way that
my trajectory really unfolded was that I ended up working for
other publishing executives in a supportive role, learning about
the business until the right opportunity opened up for me, which
happened to be at Gourmet magazine.

To me, I think you have to be willing, and open-minded, and kind
of do anything. And like I said, when it came to City Magazine,
when it came to starting Refinery, I am very much a proponent, a
supporter of, believer of trusting your gut. Interviewing, again,
is just like dating. It’s like really paying attention to, “Can I
see myself here?” “Is this something I am going to really feel
regret if I don’t get this job or if I don’t go out for this
job?”

I think the other thing is when someone comes into your midst who
has experience that you really admire, like just go out of your
way to ask, like, even if you can have a 20-minute conversation
with them. That’s just what you have to do. I cannot tell you how
many people I have cold-emailed or cold-called over the last 25
years, people I’ve admired, many of them never responded, which
is totally fine, but some of them did respond. I think that those
are the sort of encouraging moments that remind you that you’re
on the right path and that you have to keep tapping those kinds
of people in order to propel yourself forward because we don’t do
it alone. I mean, I guess if you’re a novelist or something you
do it alone, but for most of us, we need other people. We depend
on each other. When you remember that, you really become
tremendously respectful and appreciative of what other people
bring into your life and what you, in turn, bring to theirs.

Feloni: Well, thank you so much, Christene.

Barberich: You’re welcome. Thanks for having me.