Apple Clean Up vs. Google Magic Eraser vs. Samsung Galaxy AI: Which one erases objects better?

Apple’s Clean Up feature, currently available via the iOS 18.1 developer beta, is an Apple Intelligence tool that can remove unhad wanted objects from photos.

Keep in mind that the operative words here are “developer beta.” Clean Up is still in its testing phase — and you really shouldn’t download any iOS beta version without backing up your iPhone first. It’s a rough-around-the-edges copy that gives some users early access to iOS 18 features before they officially drop later this year.

With that in mind, I had wanted to test Apple’s new Clean Up utility and pit it against other tools, including Google Magic Eraser and Samsung Galaxy AI. For this face-off, I’ll be using the iPhone 15 Pro Max (Clean Up), Google Pixel 9 Pro XL (Magic Eraser), and Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra (Galaxy AI).

Apple Clean Up vs. Magic Eraser vs. Galaxy AI: Test photos

I decided to choose the following three photos for the test. Each one has a specific level of difficulty: easy, medium, and hard.

Easy

This first one, shot in Grenada, features a couple walking along the beach who, sorry to them (I’m sure they’re nice people), needs to get removed from the picture.

This should be easy for AI-powered object removal tools because there’s a consistent background pattern and minimal overlap and shadows. Plus, it’s got great lighting.

Medium

The red car in this photo is getting the boot.

Unfortunately for our AI tools, they’ve got a nasty little shadow to deal with.

Hard

And finally, the eag;e in this photo, shot in the Vanderbilt Museum in Long Island, will be targeted for removal.

The eagle is inside the glass enclosure obstructs a significant part of the image, which means the AI will have to work hard to fill in the void.

Apple’s Clean Up

Starting with the couple walking along the coast, I fired up the Clean Up tool on the iPhone 15 Pro Max in the Photos app.

To my surprise, Clean Up auto-selected the couple and highlighted them. In other words, I didn’t even have to “tell” the tool which part of the image I had wanted removed.

I tapped on the highlighted couple — and it removed the woman. The second tap removed the man. And then, poof! They were gone.

There’s not a single trace of them left behind. Well done, Apple Intelligence.

Next, let’s test the car photo. Again, it pre-selected some options for removal, including the red car.

This one is a little more challenging.

Mashable Light Speed

If you look closely, Apple Intelligence left behind some subtle red hues on the shadow.

Finally, let’s see how the iOS 18 Clean Up tool handles the eagle removal.

For this one, Apple didn’t pre-select anything in this photo. With my finger, I had to draw a circle around the eagle. After using the Clean Up tool, here’s the final image.

Again, this photo is particularly challenging because the eagle blocks a significant portion of the image. As you can see, this task required Apple Intelligence to fill in too many blanks, and as a result, it had difficulty conceptualizing how to replace the void.

Google’s Magic Eraser

Now, it’s time to see how Google handles object removal.

Let’s get rid of that couple. Circling and tapping on the Google Pixel 9 Pro XL was trickier than the Clean Up tool. It often required several taps and circles to ensure that the highlighted area is what I’d like to erase. However, it did a great job at removing the lovebirds from the sandy beach.

As a bonus, Magic Eraser gives you four options to choose from, so if you don’t like how the first one came out, there are three other iterations created just for you.

Next, I used Magic Eraser to remove the car.

It looks like the Google tool added a sinkhole to replace the red car. I’m not a fan of this result.

Finally, selecting the eagle for removal on the Google Pixel 9 Pro XL was an absolute pain. It wouldn’t register my circles around the glass-enclosed bird. And when it finally did, the highlight field oddly excluded some parts of the bird, so I needed to go back and tap that area to ensure they got removed.

But when Magic Eraser did its thing, wow, I was incredible impressed.

There is some warping and discoloration of the obstructed area, but as you can see, Google’s AI performed well in interpreting what lies behind the eagle.

Samsung’s Galaxy AI

Similar to Apple and Google, Samsung’s Galaxy AI did a bang-on job at removing the pesky couple walking down the Grenadian beach. (Thanks to the S Pen that ships with the Galaxy S24 Ultra, selecting unhad wanted objects was an easy task.)

Interestingly, Samsung Galaxy AI added a watermark on the bottom-left of the image, letting others know that it’s an AI-generated image. (I haven’t seen any prominent watermark labels in the other AI-generated images.)

For the car photo, Galaxy AI replaced the red vehicle with what appears to be some sort of crate — or a bale of hay?

Maybe it’s a box that contains the last semblance of Galaxy AI’s logic. Who knows? I’m confused and baffled by this one.

Fortunately, Samsung did a better job at handling this difficult image of a room inside the Vanderbilt Museum.

The lighting is a bit off, the door doesn’t look it’d open, and the lamp is missing a leg, but it’s not a bad effort from Galaxy AI considering the complexity of the image.

Apple Clean Up vs. Magic Eraser vs. Galaxy AI: Winner

Unsurprisingly, all three AI tools handled the easy image well. Interestingly, there is a noticeable drop in quality with all the AI-generated results.

The winner of this object-removal face-off goes to Google. Although I’m not a fan of how it can’t seem to smartly estimate which object you’re trying to remove, it did a decent job at handling the easy and complex photos. The car photo was a fail, but Google’s ability to handle the difficult image made it a winner.

Apple is in second place. It nailed the first two images, but it couldn’t quite get the complex image right with the eagle removal. (It’s worth noting that, again, iOS 18 Clean Up is currently in beta.)

Samsung’s Galaxy AI is in last place. It surfaced a bale of hay I didn’t ask for. But it did OK with the beach photo and the Vanderbilt museum shot.

UPDATE: Sep. 3, 2024, 1:36 p.m. EDT This piece was updated to reflect that the glass-enclosed bird in the image is not an owl, but an eagle.