Munich is at bubble risk.Michael Dalder/Reuters
- At least six cities around the world are at risk of having housing bubbles, according to UBS’ 2018 Global Real Estate Bubble Index.
- There are affordability crises in many more cities because housing costs have risen faster than incomes.
- Policymakers will need to step in, but the appropriate response could be challenging to nail down.
Housing costs are rising in almost every major city in the world.
At least six are at risk of being in a bubble, defined as a persistent rise in prices to the point where properties are well above their fundamental value.
“Most households can no longer afford to buy property in the top financial centers without a substantial inheritance,” UBS said in its 2018 Global Real Estate Bubble Index.
“Rents continue to consume a significant share of income.”
Policymakers will be required to intervene in affordability crises, by granting subsidies to first-time homebuyers, for example.
But other policies could be more detrimental, UBS said. If governments impose heavy property taxes in expensive cities, they could chase away foreign investors. They could also cause prices to plummet too quickly, hurting existing homeowners who want to sell.
Bubbles are often hard to identify until they burst, but UBS has handpicked six cities that are at “bubble risk.” Only two of the major cities they examined — Boston and Singapore — were considered “fairly valued.”
Here’s the list of cities on bubble watch in ascending order:
London
“The UBS Global Real Estate Bubble Index score for London declined for the second straight year but remains in the bubble-risk zone. Overall, inflation-adjusted prices are more than 10% higher than in 2007, when the last bubble burst, while rents have stayed roughly stable and real incomes have gone down by 10%.
… The relative weakness of the city’s housing market can be attributed to a few causes. First, housing remains unaffordable for London’s citizens … Second, the prime segment is hurt by higher stamp duties for luxury and buy-to-let properties … Third, inflation continues to erode the purchasing power of local residents.”
Amsterdam
“In the last four quarters prices climbed by 12% in inflation-adjusted terms. They are now 60% higher than in 2013.
Their ongoing explosive growth was fueled by the strongest income increase since 2013 among all cities and attractive financing conditions. The city’s housing price rise has more than doubled nationwide averages in the last five years. Given the highly strained affordability, a tightening of lending conditions might end the boom rather abruptly.”
Vancouver
“Imbalances increased again as house prices rose in the past four quarters at a double-digit rate in real terms. Real prices have doubled in 12 years. The imbalances are mitigated somewhat by income growth and above-average rental growth of 5–7% in nominal terms over the last four quarters.
As the government tries to contain speculation, the tax burden is rising for high-end property buyers and foreign purchasers. The already strained affordability will become an acute issue if mortgage rates rise further, one that may halt the local market boom.”
Toronto
Akin Oyedele/Business Insider
“Since the waning of the housing frenzy in the middle of last year, prices have stabilized over the past four quarters. In inflation-adjusted terms, they are 50% higher than five years ago.
Last year’s ‘fair housing plan,’ which imposed taxes on foreign purchases and vacant apartments and implemented stricter rent controls, probably contributed to the cooling.
Higher mortgage costs and tighter lending standards should limit the upside for the time being. But a short-term weakening of the Canadian dollar may again attract foreign buyers.”
Munich
“Real prices have doubled in the last 10 years and seem to be continuing on an explosive trajectory.
Nominal rents jumped 9% last year, reflecting record low vacancies, so affordability goes on deteriorating. Purchasing a 60m2 (650 sqft) flat requires of a skilled services employee an all-time high of eight accumulated years of income.
Construction has already risen significantly in recent years. Should mortgage rates pick up, a correction seems likely.”
Hong Kong
“The market is chronically undersupplied. Demand remains buoyant thanks to the residential market’s high appeal to local and foreign investors alike. So over the last decade its affordability has fallen the most among the cities considered in this study.
Even for highly skilled workers, property ownership is now out of reach. With citizens priced out of their own market, political pressure has mounted to curb price growth. Recently, the government announced an occupancy tax for vacant, completed units to encourage developers to sell them as quickly as possible, in an effort to improve supply.”
